Guilty Hands: My Bloody Valentine Collection (Deadly Gifts Series Book 2)

The first book in the Bloody Valentine Collection!! 💕

A Valentine's killer with major grudges turns them into revengeful kills. His way of taking action is meticulously planned and executed. He's obsessed with getting under Rachel's skin and spinning her life out of control. She is left with constantly looking over her shoulder waiting for him to strike again. The unease never lets up.

Jessica gives you bread crumbs of the why and when it's fully revealed, it will leave you shaken and shocked.

This psychological horror novelette wastes zero time pulling you into a twisted, obsessive mind where revenge isn’t just a motive — it’s a lifestyle. The concept alone? Chilling. A man who hunts “thieves,” not just of money, but of emotional and personal things he believes were stolen from him? That’s the kind of villain that crawls under your skin because he thinks he’s justified.

And that’s what makes this so unsettling.

The tension in this story is razor sharp. It’s not loud, chaotic horror — it’s quiet, creeping dread. The kind where someone is watching. Waiting. Planning. The calculated nature of his revenge makes it feel disturbingly intimate. Every move he makes toward Rachel feels deliberate, controlled, and terrifyingly patient.

Rachel’s situation is especially chilling because death isn’t his goal. Ruin is. And honestly? That psychological warfare hits harder than physical violence ever could. Watching him slowly infiltrate the corners of her life made my stomach twist in the best thriller-loving way.

For a novelette, this packs an impressive punch. It’s tight, intense, and doesn’t waste a single page. By the end, I felt like I needed a minute to just sit there and process.

Perfect for readers who love:
• Obsession-driven psychological horror
• Morally warped, unreliable villains
• Slow-burn stalking tension
• Dark Valentine’s Day reads

This isn’t a love story. It’s a cautionary tale wrapped in menace. And I devoured it

“Guilty Hands” by Jessica Lynn Sorensen is a dark, revenge-filled highlight in the My Bloody Valentine collection. This psychological horror thriller novella is intense, unsettling, and beautifully twisted. The atmosphere is heavy and the revenge is ruthless. Short but powerful, it delivers a chilling punch that lingers long after the final page.